Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Rail Road Traffic Tells Of Decling Demand, But Known Demand


Economic Weakness Seems To Loom

Very telling of economic activity is the Association of American Rail Roads (AARR) weekly traffic report. Railroad reports show shipment volume among various goods and commodities on a weekly basis, and are compared year over year.

Rail shipments actually correspond with other economic numbers, demonstrating economic connections. In many previous articles I wrote about support in retail coming from gas stations, vehicle sales and building material retailers. Economic evidence of these propositions are supported by rail shipments.

Two things stand out of note in rail activity. Firstly, declines in rail shipments of grain and farm products. Secondly, an overall weakening in shipment activity, perhaps corresponding with softening in manufacturing.

AARR last reported on March 22 showing results for the week of March 17. Data reveals that rail car shipments for the week declined by 5.3% versus the same week a year ago March 2011. Intermodal containers, very well suited for export purposes, are nonetheless up 2%. Intermodal containers can ship wheat, apparels, cars, lumber, etc. But are noted here especially for their common use in export activity.

For the 11 weeks ending March 17, AARR reports that rail car shipments declined 1.8% versus the same period of 2011. Intermodal, on the other hand and for the same period, increased by 2.3%. March  rail car numbers are trending with February shipments, which were down .3% for the first 7 weeks of 2012, versus year ago results.

Knowing the story means knowing that intermodal shipping unit numbers are progressively becoming ever closer to rail car unit numbers. Progressing numbers of intermodal units perhaps tells of ultimate export activity, or at least a search to move a good or commodity among various forms of transportation, in increasing numbers. Maybe simply a search to overcome U.S. infrastructure deficits.

Real Weakness Can Show A Change In Dynamic

March activity among particular commodity groups tend to reflect activity in retail sales, but show developing dynamics. Developing numbers are grain shipments for March 2012 versus March 2011 being down a considerable -8.4% year/year for the month, and down -10.3% for the eleven weeks ending March 17. Farm products excluding grain look more concerning, with a decline of -21.9% versus March 2011 and a decline of -12.4% for the 11 week period ending March 17.

Food and Grain Mill products are also showing noted declines. Surmising causation of these declines is the expectation of greater than expected agricultural production. Perhaps due to weather and also sustained inventories. Also added to grain and farming declines might include the discontinuation of the federal subsidy on ethanol.

Existing Strength Remains Strong

Advancing on the rail line are our typical suspects. Petroleum up 32% for the period and for the 11 weeks, up some 27.6%. Such results show more a consequence of pipeline and tanker deficits than actual demand. Rail is now moving where capacity in conventional transport can't currently increase. How many barrels of oil can one put into an intermodal container?

Aside from Petroleum, we have cars rising 15. 5% and 19.4%; stone, clay and glass 11.3% and 8.4%; metals at 8.2% and 11%.

All of these show the strength in not only the need for oil and gas to find a new way around the country and into export terminals, but also demand shown in retail. While gas retail has ultimately increased due to price, and new production searches for delivery avenues; vehicle sales seem to be organic. Vehicles have supported associated industries such as metals and glass. A more recent component is building materials and home improvement. Apparel sales have also demonstrated strength.

Given the guide of indicators, weakness seems generally present. A few components have lead with considerable strength. But for how long, and will the other growing sectors develop.

The seriously weak components must be investigated, being grain, food, coal.

No comments:

Post a Comment